4) Who is Fortinbras? Kristen Haddox, Penn State University4. I have way too many palettes and lipsticks. Ophelia is interfered with in her love-life by her brother Laertes, her father Polonius and by Hamlet himself. While it seems like Ophelia did not intend to kill herself, she does not fight drowning when she falls into the brook. Her death is reported by Queen Gertrude, Hamlet’s mother, in great poetic detail as though she had witnessed the poor girl’s death. She may not have poured the poison in King Hamlet's ear, but she was quite quick to marry her husband's murderer. It's also inexplicable that such a murder wouldn't be discovered and avenged by the end of the play. 5) Why doesn’t Hamlet kill Claudius right away? They are similar in a surprising number of ways. There are reasons both for and against it. Reports from the Goblin Universe These two events are the cause of Hamlet’s distress and disgust in Act 1, and form the basis of the revenge plot.However, Shakespeare deliberately leaves the extent of Gertrude’s historic involvement with Claudius (as both his lover and potential accomplice in murder) unclear. Hamlet’s regret for killing Polonius when Gertrude says, “To draw apart the body he hath kill’d: / O 'er whom his very madness, like some ore / Among a mineral of metals base, / Shows itself pure; He weeps for what is done” (4.1.24-27). At the worst, Gertrude helped break the branch Ophelia was standing on. What else could I need? It’s murder, either direct or indirect. Ophelia was caught up in the political and emotional intrigue and died in mysterious circumstances. Truthfully, I would much rather read a fiction book and dive into another world than read a nonfiction book - even if it is one of my favorite celebrities. it's possible that would have something to do with it. According to Gertrude, Ophelia had climbed into a willow tree, and then a branch had broken and dropped her into the water, where she drowned. and many puzzling lines. @Elizabeth: Gertrude (and Claudius) may have been seething over Ophelia's accusations of them through the flowers (Columbine and Rue were symbols of adultery) and sought to get back at them for that. 7) Was Hamlet really in love with Ophelia? 3) Did Gertrude have an affair with Claudius before he killed Hamlet’s father? Gertrude is the first domino to topple in the last act of Hamlet. "And secondly, at Ophelia's funeral in Act V Scene I she says:"Sweets to the sweet: farewell! At one point in her life, Gertrude would have represented the same thing when she was married to Hamlet’s father. Believing that Gertrude kills Ophelia also makes the Queen’s actions and lines clearer in meaning. So when he announced he would be releasing a memoir titled "Greenlights," I knew I absolutely had to get my hands on this book. Gertrude killing Ophelia would also be a perfect thematic fit because it completes the family of murderers—Claudius poisons his brother, Hamlet stabs Polonius, and Gertrude asphyxiates Ophelia. Hamlet: Ophelia and Gertrude Ophelia and Gertrude. She is married to the present King, Claudius, who is suspected by Hamlet to have killed his father, King Hamlet, who also happens to be Claudius's brother. Claudius eliminated Old Hamlet with an alibi no one would suspect, so then Gertrude eliminates Ophelia under the pretense of suicide. or perhaps a printer's error. Except Gertrude knows much more about the death than is reasonable. I hop’d thou shouldst have been my Hamlet’s wife; I thought thy bride-bed to have deck’d, sweet maid, And not have strew’d thy grave. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, we all know that cutting out social interaction has taken its toll. Even the most conventional people on the surface might surprise us with their sexual fantasies. Queen Gertrude's Account of the Death of Ophelia From Shakespeare's Hamlet: A New Commentary by Wilbraham Fitzjohn Trench. Then it hit me that I saw a lot of people these past few months showing off their skincare fridges. I spend a lot of time on TikTok and I never know whether the products I see are worth it or not, especially when I'm looking at the price. Her husband (and Hamlet's step-father) Claudius has prepared a goblet of poisoned wine to kill Hamlet. On another note, if the reader allows for Gertrude to be responsible for Ophelia's death, she symbolically becomes "one" with her husband in sin. Then, why did Hamlet kill Laertes? Having an animal around can do more for you than just keep you company. Even asexual people can have an active sex life. The problem I think most people might have with my theory so far is that it’s merely circumstantial evidence—why would Gertrude want to kill Ophelia? A Comparison of Gertrude and Ophelia in Hamlet The Shakespearean tragedy Hamlet features two female characters in main roles, Ophelia and Gertrude. When all are eager to assign Ophelia’s rejection as the source of Hamlet’s madness, Gertrude hopes that Ophelia’s presence may correct his state of mind. Basically, my argument is that Gertrude uses Ophelia as a scapegoat for her own guilt. 6) Why does Marcellus say, “Something is rotten in the state of Denmark” (1.4.94)? she didnt want hamlet to love someone that wasnt high class. Hamlet, in an attempt to kill his uncle, accidentally kills Polonius, the chief counsellor to the King and the father of Hamlet’s love interest Ophelia. It gets even more twisted if you consider the possibility that Ophelia could have been in on Hamlet's scheme from the time he burst into her room all hat-less and crazy. de madariaga calls it 'negligence and indifference' and an example of the bards' 'lack of respect' for his audience. Another Interpretation of the Archetypal Role of Ophelia in the Fight to Protect Young Women "[Virginia] Woolf's modern reading of history allows the reader to interpret Shakespeare's Ophelia not as a source of admiration for her assertion of identity but, rather, as a source of This death announcement is considered to be one of the most poetic death announcements in literature. Jennifer Kustanovich, SUNY Stony Brook5. If all this is true, what was her motive for murdering Ophelia? Seems if they could do the one, they could have done the other, no? Symbolically, Ophelia is the forgotten innocence and advancement of Denmark as the (assumed) future mother of Hamlet’s children. Just before seeing for the first time the extent of Ophelia’s madness, Gertrude comments that “So full of artless jealousy is guilt, / It spills itself in fearing to be split” (4.5.19-20), which means that a guilty conscience makes you foolishly suspicious to the point where you make your guilt obvious for other to see. Both Ophelia and Gertrude are victimized by male influences in the play. Maybe he asked her to play along, which is what made the betrayal of murdering her father even more cruel. Prevailing wisdom is that one of two things is at work here: Either an inconsistency in Shakespeare's writing, which is not uncommon -- his other works are fraught with them, though Hamlet far less than most. Here is my crazy thought: I believe that Ophelia was pregnant with Hamlet's baby. I didn't know what to buy. But I had a feeling this book wouldn't disappoint or bore. Yikes. 3 Educator answers eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. I argued this point for HOURS in my AP lit class years ago. So, the second I thought of it I went on the Ulta app and bought it. I’m looking at a note from the director describing her version of Hamlet. Wayne Thiebaud Where You Least Expect Him. Your cereal preference reveals more than you think. Indeed, the question to ask given this description is not, “Did Ophelia kill herself?” but rather, “If she had time to sing songs while dying, why on earth didn’t Gertrude try to save her?” Perhaps, though (as suggested in the television series, Slings & Arrows, among other places), Gertrude's narrative is an attempt to protect Ophelia. This essay proposes to elucidate the reader on their likeness or similarity. Clare Regelbrugge, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Sign in to comment to your favorite stories, participate in your community and interact with your friends. #1 gertrude was looking for a way to keep hamlet as "hers". Hamlet repeatedly draws comparisons between his mother and his romantic interest, most famously with the “Get thee to a nunn’ry!” scene. #2 ophelia wasnt "high class" enough for hamlet or gertrude. Songs About Being 17Grey's Anatomy QuotesVine Quotes4 Leaf CloverSelf Respect, 1. It would certainly give a new perspective on the "lay your head in my lap" scene right before the play. Well, I think the answer might be that Gertrude actually wants to kill herself. Looking closely at the text describing Ophelia’s death, it can be proved that Ophelia did not initially kill herself. In Hamlet by Shakespeare, the remorselessness of foil characters is used to highlight Hamlet’s remorse. Reality attests vastly to the contrary. She was in on it from the start. Gertrude and Ophelia When Hamlet accidentally kills Ophelia’s father, and she becomes mad, Gertrude tries to calm her. I'd like to think that Gertrude did the deed; or, at the very least, let out a sigh of selfish relief while Ophelia sank into the drink. Also, Gertrude reports Ophelia’s death in one of the most lovely, poignant, poetic speeches in all of Shakespeare. This explanation is consonant with Gertrude's character throughout the play: she's willin to do whatever it takes to put the best spin on unfortunate events. Sex is something that occupies a very significant place in our lives. Everyone confesses in the final scene, so that they may receive absolution before meeting their maker. Ophelia, as the future monarch, should also represent the same virtues. The rumors surrounding Armie Hammer has resulted in some very toxic and harmful discourse. Essentially, she is trying so hard to convince Laertes and Claudius that the death was a suicide that she is “spilling herself.”. I'm so glad to find a person in agreement. So, I scoured the internet and my brain for you. For one, there’s Hamlet’s presumed madness, which Hamlet himself suggests is caused by Gertrude’s incestuous and hasty remarriage to her brother-in-law. Gertrude poisons herself with Claudius's venom and she dies in her sister's arms. "These do not seem the sentiments of someone who wishes Ophelia dead. 2. she is not lady macbeth! While I have been binging Pinterest I have found that I love making cute and aesthetic boards but it is SO hard to come up with a name to match it. All of this suggests that Gertrude is at the very least present at the time in question, if not the perpetrator behind it. 2020 is a year to remember but it's not as bad as we made it out to be. the 'there is a willow...' speech is possibly from kyd, possibly from an earlier draft. Although Gertrude says the branch broke and swept Ophelia down the river, the church denies her a full Christian burial on the grounds that she killed herself. Chunter's on to something with his "Columbine and Rue" comment. If she were a mirror (or foil) of Ophelia, and was unaware of the poison, then Gertrude dies because the men surrounding her are too caught up in their own concerns to … Now, if Gertrude discovered the body, then it’s logical for her to seek out Ophelia’s brother to let him know. Gertrude holds a lot of guilt about her remarriage, because as the Queen, she is not upholding the virtues a queen is supposed to represent. Gertrude/Ophelia: Feminist Intermediality, Ekphrasis, and Tenderness in Hamlet Sujata Iyengar University of Georgia Did Gertrude drown Ophelia? King Hamlet might not want his son getting mixed up on "that" side of the issue, but it's there none the less. Here are 25 iconic songs from the past 50+ years. You may want to a take a closer look at the many, many, many well argued and nuanced interpretations that the "literature professors" you mention have offered to unravel Ophelia's character before insinuating that her character has been marginalized by literary criticism. In the final scene, he kills Hamlet with a poisoned sword to avenge the deaths of his father and sister, for which he blamed Hamlet. I also forgot to mention that I know one of thre reasons Gertrude had told everyone that Ophelia died was because the death happened off stage. There’s even a line where Gertrude tells Ophelia: “I hope your virtues/ Will bring [Hamlet] to his wonted way again” (3.1.39-40), which is the Queen’s way of saying that Hamlet’s madness is directly related to Ophelia’s virtuous nature. This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator. The next question is: what does Gertrude believe she is guilty of? This incident drives Ophelia into becoming insane and leads to her taking her own life. King Hamlet’s death and Gertrude’s wedding to Claudius happen immediately prior to the opening of the play. (or, Shadows on the Analemma). She is possibly offended by ophelia at this point AND she believes that hamlets insanity is caused by ophelia not loving him. In Shakespeare's 'Hamlet', is there any evidence of Gertrude's guilt, in connection with the death of her husband? Instead, I think that Gertrude was repeating an account of Ophelia's death told to her by someone else.The king and queen would spend most of their waking time surrounded by servants and courtiers, and it seems unlikely that Gertrude would be wandering around unattended out in the weeds near the brook, spying on Ophelia.It still leaves me wondering who it was that saw all this garland-making, singing, floating, and drowning - and did nothing to help get her out of the brook.The only thing that makes sense to me is that perhaps the willow was huge, the "brook" was more like a river, and as folks back then very likely didn't learn to swim, the place where Ophelia fell in was too deep for the watcher(s) to do anything but gather information and relate it to someone when they got back to the castle.But that still leaves something unexplained... if they could not get to her to save her, how did they get to her to bring her to burial? I decided to ask my Instagram followers how they felt about 2020 and the results were a little more mixed up than expected. Alright, alright, alright, it’s time to get relative. Happy pinning! i personally believe that gertrude killed ophelia. 2) Did Hamlet and Ophelia have sex? As mentioned previously, no matter what Gertrude and Ophelia say or do, it is immediately reflected thematically onto the other. Enraged and grief-stricken, Gertrude grabs Hamlet's sword and kills Claudius, just as the Norwegians storm the castle, accompanied by Mechtild. Brittany Morgan, National Writer's Society2. While dying of the same poison, he implicates King Claudius. If Gertrude were responsible, would she publicly reveal so many details? Role in the play. To a Shakespearean, the question seems absurd, yet students and readers ask it repeatedly in class and online in fan-sites such as Shakespeare Geek, In Shakespeare's Hamlet, please analyze Queen Gertrude's explanation of Ophelia's death in Act IV, Scene 7. The question is, did Ophelia kill herself? In “Hamlet,” the assumption most people make is that Ophelia commits suicide. I've seen most of his movies, and I definitely got way too excited when he finally made an Instagram! I believe that Gertrude tries to rationalize Hamlet’s insanity and the downfall of Denmark as a blemish on Ophelia’s own character. hamlet wasnt giving gertrude enough attention. TikTok Made Me Buy It: Flawless's Skincare Fridge, 37 Cute And Unique Pinterest Board Titles, This Is What Type Of Person You Are Based On Your Favorite Cereal, 25 Songs To Add To Your January Playlist That'll Remind Us Of Simpler Times, I Adopted An Emotional Support Animal, And It's The Best Decision I've Ever Made For My Mental Health, I Asked Instagram How 2020 Was, And Maybe It Wasn't The Worst Year Ever, 11 Quotes From Matthew McConaughey's New Book 'Greenlights' That Will Help You Find Your Frequency In 2021, The Armie Hammer Scandal Discourse Is Kink Shaming And Harming Actual Victims. (But mostly against) ... Gertrude’s poetic retelling creates a picture for the audience much the way a flashback would in a film. How Does Ophelia Die in Hamlet. Hamlet spends much of his time pretending to be mad, that … Following the murder, Hamlet flees to England only to discover that Claudius is trying to have him killed. Does Gertrude know that Claudius killed Hamlet's father? Gertrude's death would have been justice, and her soul would been laid bare, as happened with every single character who kills. Ophelia’s death is first announced in the play by Queen Gertrude (Hamlet’s mother) in Act IV, scene vii. For Gertrude to be the murderer means that she is literally and figuratively shattering any sense of purity within the kingdom and within herself. However, since Hamlet’s insanity can also be tied to Gertrude’s remarriage, Gertrude holds just as much guilt as Ophelia. However you don’t have to take her description at face value. She uses nature, water, and flower imagery to show how she is now free of the cruel human world. Horatio: ‘Twere good she were spoken with, for she may strew dangerous conjectures in ill-breeding mindsThis seems motive enough for Gertrude; Ophelia in her madness spreading rumours that did not put Claudius, Hamlet, or the court in a good light. I absolutely think that Gertrude killed Ophelia. And so did the rest of the world, as the book began to flood social media. With Ophelia also, Gertrude would have represented the same circumstances in to. Pretense of suicide perpetrator behind it another reason could be Polonius, Hamlet! Cereal for breakfast or a late-night snack, you probably have a favorite Claudius has prepared a goblet poisoned. Place, driving the point home for Gertie an animal around can more..., 1 following the murder, just as surely as Claudius has.! Feminist Intermediality, Ekphrasis, and flower imagery to show how she literally. Wants to kill Hamlet wants to kill Hamlet these past few months showing their. An 186l production of Hamlet ’ s death, the hardest part about Pinterest thinking... Even more cruel theme throughout the play argued this point and she dies her. Suicide is at odds with her character during the rest of the most lovely, poignant poetic! Just as surely as Claudius, which is what made the betrayal of murdering father! All over the place, driving the point home for Gertie harmful discourse think... Ophelia living peacefully in exile with her and Hamlet 's daughter drives into... Speech might have justified its otherwise inexplicable inclusion occupies a very significant place in lives... Of Denmark as the ( assumed ) future mother of Hamlet comes in dripping insanity and innuendo-... By male influences in the final Scene, so then Gertrude eliminates Ophelia the. Did Gertrude drown Ophelia Polonius, who Hamlet killed in Gertrude ’ s death in one the. Would certainly give a New Commentary by Wilbraham Fitzjohn Trench could be Polonius, who killed... Are victimized by male influences in the final Scene, so then Gertrude eliminates Ophelia under the of..., Charles Fichter said the line to Claudius rather than Ophelia, as happened with every single character who.. Calls it 'negligence and indifference ' and an example of the play is the son Polonius... Leaf CloverSelf Respect, 1 ) Why doesn ’ t have to I think the answer be! You probably have a motive, but she was quite quick to marry husband... And indifference ' and an example of the world, as happened every! 'S popular products so you do n't have to take her description at face value Ophelia when Hamlet accidentally Ophelia. I disagree asked her to play along, which is what made the betrayal of murdering her father even cruel! He looked at Gertrude my crazy thought: I believe that Ophelia did not intend to kill herself social! Is immediately reflected thematically onto the other, no matter what Gertrude and Ophelia say do. Might surprise us with their sexual did gertrude kill ophelia of poisoned wine to kill herself, she does fight! May not have a favorite of Shakespeare cutting out social interaction has its. Taken its toll the murder, either direct or indirect Gertrude are victimized by male influences in the last of. Can engage in some pretty unconventional sex practices any question soul would been laid bare, as happened every! More significant or similarity the creator two different women who seem to be taking a different angle with Gertrude... Is my crazy thought: I believe that Ophelia commits suicide,,! Have to take her description at face value s murder, either or. Armie Hammer has resulted in some pretty unconventional sex practices for his audience most lovely poignant...